Copied from a Facebook friend….
Can a religion be narcissistic? Yes, a religion—or more accurately, the way a religion is practiced, interpreted, or institutionalized—can exhibit narcissistic traits. In this context, the term narcissistic refers to patterns of behavior or attitudes that center on self-importance, superiority, entitlement, or lack of empathy.
Characteristics of a Narcissistic Religion:
1. Claiming Exclusivity: The belief that one religion is the only true or valid path to salvation can become narcissistic if it fosters superiority or dismisses the value of other faiths.
2. Demanding Absolute Loyalty: When a religion expects unquestioning allegiance, punishes dissent, or labels those who leave as inferior or sinful, it may mirror narcissistic control.
3. Grandiosity: A religion may exhibit narcissism by glorifying its own history, leaders, or doctrines to an exaggerated degree while ignoring flaws or mistakes.
4. Lack of Empathy: If a religion dismisses or invalidates the experiences, questions, or struggles of individuals in favor of maintaining its authority, it may show narcissistic tendencies.
5. Exploitation: Some religious institutions may manipulate members emotionally, financially, or socially, prioritizing the organization’s goals over the well-being of individuals.
6. Us vs. Them Mentality: Religions can cultivate an exclusive in-group/out-group dynamic, fostering disdain or fear of outsiders.
Distinguishing Narcissism from Passion
Not all strong religious beliefs or practices are narcissistic. Passion for one’s faith is healthy when it coexists with humility, respect for others, and a willingness to engage in self-reflection.
Why It Happens
Religious narcissism can arise when:
• Leadership becomes centralized and authoritarian.
• Members are taught to view questioning as rebellion.
• Historical narratives are rewritten to eliminate imperfections.
• The focus shifts from spirituality to institutional power or prestige.
Individual vs. Institutional Narcissism
An individual within a religion may behave narcissistically, but that doesn’t mean the entire religion is narcissistic. Similarly, a religious institution might exhibit these traits, but many followers could still practice the faith in loving, empathetic, and humble ways.
Historical Examples
1. Medieval Catholic Church (Prior to the Reformation)
• Grandiosity: The Church claimed to be the ultimate authority on salvation and even on political matters, controlling monarchs and nations.
• Exploitation: Practices like the selling of indulgences (payments for forgiveness of sins) manipulated people’s fear of damnation for financial gain.
• Us vs. Them: Those who questioned Church doctrine (e.g., reformers like Martin Luther) were excommunicated or persecuted.
2. Colonial Missionary Movements
• Lack of Empathy: Many colonial powers imposed their religion on indigenous peoples without understanding or respecting their cultures.
• Superiority: They often deemed native religions “pagan” or inferior, justifying forced conversions and the destruction of sacred traditions.
Modern Examples
1. Religious Fundamentalism
• Claiming Exclusivity: Some sects or denominations assert that their interpretations of scripture are the only valid ones, dismissing others as heretical or doomed.
• Authoritarian Leadership: Leaders in some groups demand unquestioning obedience, using fear or guilt to maintain control.
• Us vs. Them Mentality: Fundamentalist groups often demonize outsiders, fostering divisiveness and intolerance.
2. Prosperity Gospel Movements
• Exploitation: Preachers in this movement sometimes manipulate followers into giving large sums of money with promises of divine financial rewards.
• Grandiosity: Leaders live in opulence, claiming their wealth is evidence of God’s favor, while criticizing the faith of poorer followers.
3. Exclusive or High-Control Groups (e.g., Cults)
• Demanding Absolute Loyalty: Groups like Scientology or Jehovah’s Witnesses sometimes impose strict rules on members, ostracizing those who leave.
• Superiority: They may teach that only their members are enlightened or “saved,” fostering arrogance and isolation from broader society.
Case Study: LDS Church (Mormonism)
While not inherently narcissistic, certain practices or attitudes within the LDS Church have been criticized as potentially reflecting narcissistic traits:
1. Claiming Exclusivity:
• The Church teaches that it is the only true and living church on the face of the earth. While this inspires dedication in some, it may foster a sense of superiority over other faiths.
2. Authoritarian Leadership:
• Members are encouraged to “follow the prophet” without question. Dissent or public criticism of leadership can result in excommunication, potentially mirroring control dynamics.
3. Grandiosity in Historical Narratives:
• The LDS Church has been accused of presenting a “sanitized” version of its history, emphasizing its divinely guided origins while downplaying controversies (e.g., polygamy, Mountain Meadows Massacre).
4. Us vs. Them Mentality:
• Emphasis on being a “peculiar people” and avoiding the influences of the “world” may unintentionally create a barrier between members and non-members.
5. Exploitation:
• Some critics argue that the Church’s emphasis on tithing (mandatory 10% of income) puts undue financial pressure on members, especially those in poverty.
Here’s a specific example involving the LDS Church that can illustrate traits that might be perceived as narcissistic, particularly in its institutional behavior or teachings:
Claiming Exclusivity: The “Only True Church” Doctrine
The LDS Church teaches that it is the only true and living church on the earth, with exclusive authority to perform saving ordinances such as baptism and eternal marriage. This doctrine is rooted in revelations to Joseph Smith, particularly in Doctrine and Covenants 1:30, where God is said to declare the Church’s unique status.
Why It Might Be Seen as Narcissistic:
• Superiority: This teaching can lead to a belief that other religions, no matter how sincere their followers, lack the fullness of truth and authority.
• Lack of Empathy: Those who leave the Church or choose another path might be viewed as spiritually lost or rebellious, which can alienate them from believing family members.
• Us vs. Them Mentality: This exclusivity reinforces the idea that non-members are “the world” or outsiders, potentially fostering division.
Authoritarian Leadership: “Follow the Prophet”
The phrase “Follow the Prophet” is a central teaching, emphasizing obedience to Church leaders, who are considered God’s mouthpieces on earth. Questioning or criticizing the prophet or apostles is discouraged, and public dissent can lead to disciplinary action, including excommunication.
Why It Might Be Seen as Narcissistic:
• Control: Members are taught that disobedience to the prophet is disobedience to God. This can stifle personal agency and critical thinking.
• Demand for Loyalty: Members who publicly disagree with Church policies (e.g., issues around LGBTQ+ inclusion or historical transparency) may be labeled as apostates.
• Exploitation: This unquestioning obedience can be used to secure tithes, missionary service, and other sacrifices, prioritizing institutional goals over individual needs.
Grandiosity in History: Sanitized Narratives
For much of its history, the LDS Church has presented a simplified, faith-promoting version of its origins. For example:
• Joseph Smith’s First Vision story evolved over time, with earlier accounts emphasizing personal forgiveness and later accounts adding the idea of a divine commission to restore the true Church.
• Sensitive topics like polygamy, Joseph Smith’s use of a seer stone, or institutional racism have been minimized or reframed in ways that protect the Church’s reputation.
Why It Might Be Seen as Narcissistic:
• Grandiosity: The Church often portrays itself as a flawless, divinely guided institution while downplaying mistakes or controversies.
• Lack of Transparency: Critics argue that the Church’s approach to its history prioritizes its image over truth, potentially undermining trust.
Us vs. Them Mentality: “The World” vs. “The Saints”
The Church emphasizes the idea of being a “peculiar people” (see 1 Peter 2:9) and often teaches members to avoid worldly influences. For example:
• Members are counseled to dress modestly, avoid mainstream media, and prioritize Church service over secular commitments.
Why It Might Be Seen as Narcissistic:
• Exclusivity: This can create an “in-group” mentality, where members view themselves as morally superior to non-members.
• Division: Non-members or less-active members may feel judged or excluded, particularly in communities with a high LDS presence.
Exploitation: Tithing and Financial Transparency
The Church requires members to pay 10% of their income as tithing to remain in good standing and qualify for temple attendance. However, the Church has been criticized for its lack of financial transparency, especially after reports that it holds billions of dollars in investments.
Why It Might Be Seen as Narcissistic:
• Demanding Sacrifice: Members, including those in financial hardship, are expected to prioritize tithing over other obligations.
• Institutional Wealth: Critics argue that the Church’s focus on accumulating wealth may not align with its charitable teachings, prioritizing institutional prestige over helping the needy.
Balancing Perspective
While these examples highlight potential narcissistic traits within the LDS Church as an institution, it’s essential to note that many individual members approach their faith with genuine humility, love, and a desire to serve others. Additionally, the Church has made efforts in recent years to address some of these concerns, such as publishing historical essays and increasing transparency about controversial topics.
All I Possess 